Penny, Pete and Paul demonstrate the possibilities in public education

In some ways, Penny, Pete and Paul were very different. Penny was a blonde, blue-eyed teenager who grew up on a farm in East Central Minnesota, with 10 younger brothers and sisters. Pete, who sometimes colored his hair, lived in a western Twin Cities suburb with his single parent mom. Paul was a tall, handsome, angry African American teenager in St. Paul.

As we conclude 2012 and look ahead, their stories help illustrate the possibilities of public education.

By the time she was in 11th grade in her rural high school, Penny, was a cheerleader and member of the National Honor Society.

But there was turmoil at home. The family farm was in financial trouble. Her parents often argued. Penny assumed many responsibilities at home. Unfortunately, she looked elsewhere for love and comfort, made a mistake and became pregnant.

She was kicked off the cheerleading squad, removed from the National Honor Society and ridiculed by some students and educators. She was devastated and thought about suicide.

Fortunately a friend told her about an alternative school in the area. Penny blossomed again. She told a legislative committee that at her new school, “people didn’t judge me. They encouraged me. The school probably saved my life.”

As Penny told her story, the hearing room was very quiet. Conversations stopped. There were many moist eyes.

Pete’s parents didn’t just argue, they divorced. He often was bored in school. He wanted to drop out, but his mother convinced him to stay. So, as he later told legislators, he earned barely passing grades in “dummy English, dummy math and dummy social studies in the morning, and then worked at a fast food franchise in the afternoon.”

They liked his work and made him an assistant manager.

Then he heard about Post Secondary Enrollment Options (PSEO). The University of Minnesota allowed him to take a course. He earned an “A.” That led to attending the University of Minnesota fulltime under PSEO. He did very well.

Finally, there is Paul, from a classic inner city family facing many challenges. He was angry at the world and hated school. He made many mistakes, including fighting at his high school. Finally, he was kicked out and landed in a school where I taught. He mostly slept in classes for several weeks.

One day a teacher asked him to join a class on “Protect your Rights and Money.” Paul used “street smarts” to help solve consumer problems that families and community members referred to the class. He did well, and appeared in a newspaper story about the class.

On seeing the story, Paul told his teacher, “I often thought I might have my name in the paper; and perhaps my picture. But I never thought it would be for something good.”

Like Penny and Pete, Paul graduated. He worked for Prince, the recording artist. Then he opened a recording arts studio and encountered many other young men, years younger. They shared his love of music and dislike of traditional schools.

With help from some educators, Paul founded the High School for Recording Arts (HSRA), a charter public school that helps previously unsuccessful students develop stronger skills and positive attitudes. Students must apply to some form of higher education before they can graduate.

Recently Junior Achievement gave the school its top high school company in the United States award, because HSRA students have produced “You-Tube” videos on public service topics (like “stay in school”) under contracts from companies including State Farm Insurance and Verizon.

Over the last 40 years I’ve seen many youngsters like those above (although I did not use their real names). We need to acknowledge the power of public education and educators as we work to help reach even more. Public education is powerful.

Since 1970, Joe Nathan has been a public school teacher, administrator, parent, PTA president, and researcher. He now directs the Center for School Change. Reactions are welcome, [email protected].

Correction on Joe’s 12-16-12 column:
In Joe Nathan’s Dec. 16 column about Minnesota students scoring higher than most nations on math and science, the basic information is correct. Nathan cited recent eighth grade international tests. These show Minnesota eighth graders scoring in the “top 10.” However, he also cited results with Minnesota fourth graders. He misinterpreted the fourth grade results. There were not enough Minnesota fourth graders tested to separate out those results. The eighth grade results he reported are accurate. Nathan apologizes for his misinterpretation.